NTi MegaDipol MD300DX
The antennas from NTi have become an integral part of the SWL scene. The BoniWhip, MegaLoop ML200, MegActiv MA305 FT and others are antennas that have become well established in our hobby. So does the MegaDipol MD300DX. It was launched in May 2018. Dennis Walter from Bonito made the MegaDipol available to me for tests and comparisons.
The MD300DX is an active dipole and a so-called E-field antenna. "E-field" means it reacts mainly to the electrical part of the electromagnetic field. In contrast to the asymmetrical Whip antennas and all antennas with one rod, the MD300DX is a symmetrical receiving antenna. This has to do with her second rod, which she uses as a counterweight. It is therefore independent of the ground connection to earth. At least most. A ground connection can be useful depending on the installation location and local conditions. It's a matter of trial and error. In order for the MD300DX to develop its full potential, it should be set up outside of the domestic disturbance fog if possible. If possible, try several locations. Danke an Bonito für die Bilder.
The MD300DX is delivered with 2x 2.5m
long rods made of stainless steel wire rope. It can be flexibly
attached to trees or non-conductive masts. The manufacturer
recommends vertical installation because the active dipole offers
all-round reception and delivers full performance. With the
recommended vertical installation, however, there are some important
factors to consider that hardly anyone knows. It is essential to
ensure that no metallic masts are used. This is absolutely
important when using vertically polarized active dipoles. If a metal
mast with a short boom is used, resonances occur between the rods
and the mast and the frequency response of the antenna is
significantly disturbed. There are strong level increases or even
signal cancellation. The cable to the antenna is also very important.
The coaxial cable feed line must be at least 2 m at right angles to
the rods. Otherwise you have the same effects as with the metallic
mast.
Picture below. In order to be able to operate the MD300DX vertically, it must be mounted on a plastic mast. This is how a vertical active dipole is correctly built up.
In order to do my experiments and comparisons, I built the amplifier board of the MD300DX into a stable and larger housing in order to be able to use rigid antenna radiators. I used two 3m telescopic antennas from Buddipole. With this variant I can easily operate the antenna vertically as well as horizontally on a mast. The length of the rods can also be varied by inserting the telescopic rods.
Reception with the MD300DX (horizontally polarized)
The MD300DX
was tested for reception performance for several weeks. I
ran it horizontally for a while and compared it to the
Datong AD370. As you can see in the picture below, the
MD300DX is significantly larger than the Datong AD370, which
is mounted on the rear arm. Overall, the reception
performance of both antennas was very similar. There were
differences mainly on the lower frequencies up to about
5Mhz. If the antennas were aligned accordingly, the Russian
alpha signals could be received well on 11.9, 12.65 and
14.9KHz. The Datong brought the signals a little stronger,
but noisy. In the VLF, long wave and medium wave range, the
MD300DX was clearly ahead. The signal-to-noise ratio (SNR)
was always slightly better than the Datong. The differences
were small on the shortwave. The antennas could not be
distinguished from one another. The MD300DX of the Datong
could only pull away a bit from around 16MHz. The weakest
signals, especially in the 11m or 10m band, came more
clearly with the MD300DX or could only be heard with it.
Image below: The three alpha signals received with the MD300DX are horizontally polarized.
Reception with the MD300DX (vertically polarized)
Vertically aligned and mounted on a plastic mast, the MD300DX
ignites the receiving turbo! The signal levels, especially in the
lower bands, rise up to 25dB! Not every receiver can cope with such
strong, almost brutal levels. Cheap receivers, especially the
RTL-sticks, are hopelessly overwhelmed with this antenna. Even the
Kiwi-SDR had to give up, as did the Airspy HF+ Discovery. These
overdrive regularly in the evening hours. Only the Winradio G33DDC,
Elad FDM-S3 and the Rohde & Schwarz EK070 coped with the strong
signals of the MD300DX.
The vertical polarization offers all-round reception. This is an advantage, but also a disadvantage! No disturbances can be hidden. With horizontal polarization, you can turn the antenna and thus hide certain interferers. If the MD300DX is operated vertically, it should be located far away from the house. Preferably in the open field. The horizontal polarization is not that sensitive in this regard. But that applies to every active dipole.
Highly recommended! A top antenna! posted: 03.02.2021
|